Contesting immunities in the International Criminal Court: an analysis of the rulings of the Pre-Trial Chambers and the Appeals Chamber in Bashir Case and its outcomes

Luisa Giannini, Roberto Vilchez Yamato

Resumo


This article examines the rulings from International Criminal Court’s Pre-Trial Chambers and Appeals Chamber regarding the relationship between the law of immunities, in particular heads of state immunity, and the exercise of jurisdiction by international criminal courts in the context of the Bashir Case. It does an analysis of these decisions, highlighting the manner through which the chambers engaged with the legal reasonings presented especially by states. The goal is to identify the different forms of contestation from the actors in the field of international criminal law that were triggered by these rulings in a way that it is possible to make a correlation amongst the degree of engagement of the Chamber with outside arguments and the reaction it provoked. The article concludes that the different ways the Court deals with external actors and their reasonings will generate distinct kinds of responses, meaning that if these actors feel that the rulings are disregarding their arguments a more productive type of contestation can become an objection to the authority or legitimacy of the Court.

Palavras-chave


Bashir Case; Immunities of Heads of State; International Criminal Court; Contestation; African Union; Pre-Trial Chamber; Appeals Chamber.

Texto completo:

PDF (English)

Referências


AFRICAN UNION (AU). Decision on the International Criminal Court, Doc. EX.CL/1068(XXXII). Addis Ababa: 30th Ordinary Session of the Assembly, 2018. Available at: .

AFRICAN UNION (AU). Withdrawal Strategy Document. Addis Ababa: African Union (AU), 2017.

AKANDE, D. The Legal Nature of Security Council Referrals to the ICC and its Impact on Al Bashir’s Immunities. Journal of International Criminal Justice, v. 7, n. 2, p. 333–352, 2009.

AKANDE, Dapo. ICC Appeals Chamber Holds that Heads of State Have No Immunity Under Customary International Law Before International Tribunals. EJIL: Talk! Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

AKANDE, Dapo. ICC Issues Detailed Decision on Bashir’s Immunity (. . . At long Last . . . ) But Gets the Law Wrong. EJIL: Talk! Available at: . Accessed: 18 out. 2020.

AKANDE, Dapo. The African Union, the ICC and Universal Jurisdiction: Some Recent Developments. EJIL: Talk! Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

AKANDE, Dapo. The African Union’s Response to the ICC’s Decisions on Bashir’s Immunity: Will the ICJ Get Another Immunity Case? EJIL: Talk! Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

AKANDE, Dapo. The Bashir Appeal at the ICC. EJIL: Talk! Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

AKANDE, Dapo. The Immunity of Heads of States of Nonparties in the Early Years of the ICC. AJIL Unbound, v. 112, p. 172–176, 2018.

AKANDE, Dapo. Who Is Obliged to Arrest Bashir? EJIL: Talk! Available at: . Accessed: 5 ago. 2020.

APPEALS CHAMBER. Judgment in the Jordan Referral re Al-Bashir Appeal. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2019. Available at: .

APPEALS CHAMBER. Order inviting expressions of interest as amici curiae in judicial proceedings (pursuant to rule 103 of the Rules of Procedure and Evidence). The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2018. Available at: .

APPEALS CHAMBER. Prosecutor v. Taylor, Decision on Immunity from Jurisdiction. Freetown: Special Court for Sierra Leone (SCSL), 2004. Available at: .

APPEALS CHAMBER. Prosecutor v. Tihomir Blaskic, Judgement on the Request of the Republic of Croatia for Review of the Decision of Trial Chamber II of 18 July 1997. The Hague: International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY), 1997. Available at: .

APPEALS CHAMBER. The Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan’s appeal against the “Decision under article 87(7) of the Rome Statute on the non-compliance by Jordan with the request by the Court for the arrest and surrender [of] Omar Al-Bashir”. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2018. Available at: .

BASSIOUNI, M. Cherif. UNIVERSAL JURISDICTION UNREVISITED: THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE DECISION IN CASE CONCERNING THE ARREST WARRANT OF 11 APRIL 2000 (DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF THE CONGO V BELGIUM). The Palestine Yearbook of International Law Online, v. 12, n. 1, p. 27–48, 2002.

BATROS, Ben. A Confusing ICC Appeals Judgment on Head of State Immunity. Just Security. Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

BOISTER, N. The ICJ in the Belgian Arrest Warrant Case: Arresting the Development of International Criminal Law. Journal of Conflict and Security Law, v. 7, n. 2, p. 293–314, 2002.

BOSCHIERO, Nerina. The ICC Judicial Finding on Non-cooperation Against the DRC and No Immunity for Al-Bashir Based on UNSC Resolution 1593. Journal of International Criminal Justice, v. 13, n. 3, p. 625–653, 2015.

CRYER, Robert. Prosecuting the Leaders: Promises, Politics and Practicalities. Goettingen Journal of International Law, 2009. Available at: . Accessed: 18 out. 2020.

CRYER, Robert. The ICC and its Relationship to Non-States Parties. In: STAHN, Carsten (Org.). The law and practice of the International Criminal Court. First edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015, p. 260–280.

DEFALCO, Randle. Sudan Announces Intention to Send al-Bashir to the ICC (Kind of). Just Security. Available at: . Accessed: 20 out. 2020.

DU PLESSIS, Max; TLADI, Dire. The ICC’s immunity debate – the need for finality. EJIL: Talk! Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

GAETA, P. Does President Al Bashir Enjoy Immunity from Arrest? Journal of International Criminal Justice, v. 7, n. 2, p. 315–332, 2009.

HAQUE, Adil Ahmad. Head of State Immunity is Too Important for the International Court. Just Security. Available at: . Accessed: 20 out. 2020.

INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE (ICJ). Arrest Warrant of 11 April 2000 (Democratic Republic of the Congo v. Belgium). The Hague: [s.n.], 2002. Available at: .

JACOBS, Dov. A Sad Hommage to Antonio Cassese: The ICC’s confused pronouncements on State Compliance and Head of State Immunity. Spreading the Jam. Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

JACOBS, Dov. Q&A regarding the “Q&A REGARDING APPEALS CHAMBER’S 6 MAY 2019 JUDGMENT IN THE JORDAN REFERRAL RE AL-BASHIR APPEAL”. Spreading the Jam. Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

JACOBS, Dov. The Frog that Wanted to Be an Ox: The ICC’s Approach to Immunities and Cooperation. In: STAHN, Carsten (Org.). The law and practice of the International Criminal Court. First edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015, p. 281–304.

JACOBS, Dov. You have just entered Narnia: ICC Appeals Chamber adopts the worst possible solution on immunities in the Bashir case. Spreading the Jam. Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

KERSTEN, Mark. Not All it’s Cracked Up to Be – The African Union’s “ICC Withdrawal Strategy”. Justice in Conflict. Available at: .

KERSTEN, Mark. Sudan’s Omar al-Bashir may finally face justice for Darfur. But the work is not yet done. Justice in Conflict. Available at: . Accessed: 20 out. 2020.

KJELDGAARD-PEDERSEN, Astrid. Is the Quality of the ICC’s Legal Reasoning an Obstacle to Its Ability to Deter International Crimes? iCourts Working Paper Series, n. 191, 2020. Available at: . Accessed: 18 out. 2020.

KRISCH, Nico. The Backlash against International Courts. Völkerrechtsblog. Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

LABUDA, Patryk I. The African Union’s Collective Withdrawal from the ICC: Does Bad Law make for Good Politics? –. EJIL: Talk! Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

MADSEN, Mikael Rask; CEBULAK, Pola; WIEBUSCH, Micha. Backlash against international courts: explaining the forms and patterns of resistance to international courts. International Journal of Law in Context, v. 14, n. 2, p. 197–220, 2018.

MAO, Xiao. The Function of Amicus Curiae Participation by Legal Scholars: The Al-Bashir Appeal Case at the International Criminal Court as an Illustration. Chinese Journal of International Law, v. 18, n. 2, p. 393–424, 2019.

METTRAUX, Guénaël; DUGARD, John; DU PLESSIS, Max. Heads of State Immunities, International Crimes and President Bashir’s Visit to South Africa. International Criminal Law Review, v. 18, n. 4, p. 577–622, 2018.

MUDUKUTI, Angela. Prosecutor v. Omar Hassan Ahmad Al-Bashir, Judgment in the Jordan Referral re Al-Bashir Appeal. American Journal of International Law, v. 114, n. 1, p. 103–109, 2020.

MUDUKUTI, Angela. The state of play in the al-Bashir saga. Mail & Guardian Thought Leader, 2015. Available at: . Accessed: 12 out. 2020.

MURUNGI, Phoebe. 10 Years of the International Criminal Court (ICC): The Court, Africa, The United Nations Security Council (UNSC) and Article 16 of the Rome Statute. SSRN Electronic Journal, 2012. Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

NOUWEN, S. M. H.; WERNER, W. G. Doing Justice to the Political: The International Criminal Court in Uganda and Sudan. European Journal of International Law, v. 21, n. 4, p. 941–965, 2010.

NOUWEN, Sarah M.H. RETURN TO SENDER: LET THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE JUSTIFY OR QUALIFY INTERNATIONAL-CRIMINAL-COURT EXCEPTIONALISM REGARDING PERSONAL IMMUNITIES. The Cambridge Law Journal, v. 78, n. 3, p. 596–611, 2019.

OOSTHUIZEN, Gabriël H. Some Preliminary Remarks on the Relationship Between the Envisaged International Criminal Court and the un Security Council. Netherlands International Law Review, v. 46, n. 03, p. 313, 1999.

PAPILLON, Sophie. Has the United Nations Security Council Implicitly Removed Al Bashir’s Immunity? International Criminal Law Review, v. 10, n. 2, p. 275–288, 2010.

PEDRETTI, Ramona. Immunity of heads of state and state officials for international crimes. Leiden ; Boston: Brill Nijhoff, 2015. (Developments in international law, volume 69).

PILLAY, Navi; GOLDSTONE, Richard; KERSTEN, Mark. A Graceful Exit for South Africa’s ICC Withdrawal Plans. Justice in Conflict. Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER I. Corrigendum to the Decision Pursuant to Article 87(7) of the Rome Statute on the Failure by the Republic of Malawi to Comply with the Cooperation Requests Issued by the Court with Respect to the Arrest and Surrender of Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2011. Available at: .

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER I. Decision informing the United Nations Security Council and the Assembly of the States Parties to the Rome Statute about Omar Al-Bashir’s presence in the territory of the Republic of Kenya. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2010. Available at: .

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER I. Decision informing the United Nations Security Council and the Assembly of the States Parties to the Rome Statute about Omar Al-Bashir’s recent visit to Djibouti. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2011. Available at: .

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER I. Decision informing the United Nations Security Council and the Assembly of the States Parties to the Rome Statute about Omar Al-Bashir’s recent visit to the Republic of Chad. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2010. Available at: .

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER I. Decision on the Cooperation of the Democratic Republic of the Congo Regarding Omar Al Bashir’s Arrest and Surrender to the Court. The Hague: [s.n.], 2014. Available at: .

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER I. Decision pursuant to article 87(7) of the Rome Statute on the refusal of the Republic of Chad to comply with the cooperation requests issued by the Court with respect to the arrest and surrender of Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2011. Available at: .

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER I. Warrant of Arrest for Muammar Mohammed Abu Minyar Gaddafi. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2011. Available at: . Accessed: 14 out. 2020.

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER II. Decision on the Prosecutor’s Application for Summonses to Appear for Francis Kirimi Muthaura, Uhuru Muigai Kenyatta and Mohammed Hussein Ali. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2011. Available at: . Accessed: 9 out. 2020.

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER II. Decision under article 87(7) of the Rome Statute on the non-compliance by Jordan with the request by the Court for the arrest and surrender or Omar Al-Bashir. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2017. Available at: .

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER II. Decision under article 87(7) of the Rome Statute on the non-compliance by South Africa with the request by the Court for the arrest and surrender of Omar Al-Bashir. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2017. Available at: .

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER II. Minority Opinion of Judge Marc Perrin de Brichambaut, ICC-02/05-01/09-302-Anx. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2017. Available at: .

PRE-TRIAL CHAMBER II. Minority Opinion of Judge Marc Perrin de Brichambaut, ICC-02/05-01/09-309-Anx-tENG. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2017. Available at: .

REINOLD, Theresa. African Union v International Criminal Court: episode MLXIII (?). EJIL: Talk! Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.

SCHABAS, William A. The Special Tribunal for Lebanon: Is a ‘Tribunal of an International Character’ Equivalent to an ‘International Criminal Court’? Leiden Journal of International Law, v. 21, n. 2, p. 513–528, 2008.

SWART, Mia. The African Pinochet? Universal Jurisdiction and the Habré Case. In: WEILL, Sharon; SEELINGER, Kim Thuy; CARLSON, Kerstin Bree (Orgs.). The President on Trial: Prosecuting Hissène Habré. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2020, p. 406–415. Available at: . Accessed: 18 out. 2020.

TLADI, D. The ICC Decisions on Chad and Malawi: On Cooperation, Immunities, and Article 98. Journal of International Criminal Justice, v. 11, n. 1, p. 199–221, 2013.

TLADI, Dire. Sudan Agrees to Send Al Bashir to the ICC: What Now for the Law? Opinio Juris. Available at: . Accessed: 20 out. 2020.

TRIAL CHAMBER. In re Radovan Karadžić, Ratko Mladić and Mićo Stanišić, Decision in the Matter of a Proposal for a Formal Request for Deferral to the Competence of the Tribunal Addressed to the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina. The Hague: International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY), 1995.

TRIAL CHAMBER. Prosecutor v. Slobodan Milosevic, Decision on Preliminary Motions. The Hague: International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY), 2001. Available at: .

TRIAL CHAMBER V. Decision on the withdrawal of charges against Mr Kenyatta. The Hague: International Criminal Court (ICC), 2015. Available at: . Accessed: 10 out. 2020.

TRIFFTERER, Otto; BURCHARD, Christoph. Article 27 Irrelevance of official capacity. In: TRIFFTERER, Otto; AMBOS, Kai (Orgs.). Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court: a commentary. Third edition. München: C.H. Beck, 2016, p. 1037–1055.

UNITED NATIONS SECURITY COUNCIL. Resolution 1593 (2005). New York: United Nations Security Council, 2005. Available at: .

WEATHERALL, Thomas. Prosecutor v. Omar Al-Bashir, Judgment in the Jordan Referral Re Al-Bashir Appeal (Int’L Crim. Ct.). International Legal Materials, v. 58, n. 6, p. 1177–1233, 2019.

WOUTERS, Jan. The Judgement of the International Court of Justice in the Arrest Warrant Case: Some Critical Remarks. Leiden Journal of International Law, v. 16, n. 2, p. 253–267, 2003.

YAMATO, Roberto Vilchez. Mandado de Prisão de 11 de Abril de 2000 (República Democrática do Congo vs. Bélgica) (14 de Fevereiro de 2002). In: RORIZ, João Henrique Ribeiro; AMARAL JÚNIOR, Alberto do (Orgs.). O direito internacional em movimento: jurisprudência internacional comentada: Corte Internacional de Justiça e Supremo Tribunal Federal. Brasília: IBDC, 2016, p. 115–137.

Question and Answers - Q&A REGARDING APPEALS CHAMBER’S 6 MAY 2019 JUDGMENT IN THE JORDAN REFERRAL RE AL-BASHIR APPEAL. International Criminal Court (ICC). Available at: .

Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. Rome: [s.n.], 1998.

Sudan crisis: Ex-President Omar al-Bashir moved to prison. BBC News, 2019. Available at: . Accessed: 19 out. 2020.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.5102/rdi.v18i2.7260

ISSN 2236-997X (impresso) - ISSN 2237-1036 (on-line)

Desenvolvido por:

Logomarca da Lepidus Tecnologia